Getting my girl back

by Joe

I had a girlfriend for two years, after which we took a break. The break was supposed to help us realize how much we wanted each other back, but things continued to go bad, and we ended up completely breaking up.

After we broke up I knew she was hanging out with a guy she sort of liked, but I had a hard time letting go and we continued to hang out, maintaining a friendship. While broken up I had met a girl one night and we ended up kissing and doing a little more but I thought it felt wrong and ended up walking away.

Shortly after that my ex started to express an interest in getting back together with me. I want my ex back more than anything so this was great news, but I felt guilty about what I had done with this other girl.

So after about a month of talking about getting back together I realized for me to ever be happy with myself and for the relationship with me and my ex to work, she needed to hear this news. I finally told her about what had happened and it seemed like every forward step that we had taken was gone. She wanted nothing to do with me.

I had told myself that if I truly loved her, I had to tell her about this and if she truly loved me, we could get past it (especially since we were not together when it happened). I am not a liar but based on her reaction I feel like I messed up by telling her. If I had kept it quiet our relationship would be great but I would be hurting keeping it in.

So I guess I was just wondering if I did the right thing by telling the truth? I am still trying to get her back but do you think that I'm just annoying her? I don't want to make my situation worse and right now winning her back feels like the only thing that will help. Just looking for another female's perspective. Please help!


Hi Joe,

No, I don't think you did wrong to tell her about the other girl. If you two were really officially "broken up" at that time, then I don't feel you really did anything wrong. Sometimes it is better to keep an indiscretion to yourself and suffer in silence for your sins. But this was a little different, as you didn't really cheat on her.

I think in time she may "forgive you" and get past it. But the worst thing you can do right now is try too hard to "win her back". That WILL annoy her, and she will push you away. Just lie low for a while.

You sound like a decent sort of guy, just stay faithful from now on, don't give her any reason to distrust you at this point. But don't press her to forgive you and get back with you. She needs some time and space to sort things out. Stay near, stay faithful, be decent to her and be her best friend. If you two are meant to be together, she will eventually forgive and take you back.

If she can't get past it, you don't want to be trapped in a relationship like that anyway. You would never be forgiven.

That's my best advice to you. Time is on your side.

Good luck,


Comments for Getting my girl back

Click here to add your own comments

by: Anonymous

I just wanted to say that I lived more than half my lifetime with my husband, and now he tells me that he has held something against me for the past 34 years, and he is giving me such a hard time.

He has had affairs to pay me back because he said I hurt him. I did not have an affair but something happened to me in the past that he can't let go.(before we got married) I too thought that if you loved a person truly, nothing can stand in it's way.

Yes, stay away and give each other your space. If she loves you and feels that she can forgive you she may come back.

Just think, when she was apart from you; how do you know she didn't do anything with someone else? If she knows she did, maybe she will come to her senses and see things differently.

Good luck and hang in there.

Right thing
by: Anonymous

You did the right thing, sometimes it just doesn't seem like it. Trust me, I know. Sometimes stepping back is the only thing to do. She will see she's missing out on a great guy, and when she does, she will come back to you. Sit back and let it run it's course. Good luck.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Dear Stella.